Skip to main content



1. Breathtaking Diamonds

Hand-Selected for Perfection by GIA Diamond Graduates

Every diamond we offer in our exclusive Gerald Peters Collection undergoes an intricate screening process in order to ensure exquisite beauty for a lifetime. Each diamond is screened by at least three people before reaching our customers: the diamond buyer, Gerald Peters’ owner, and finally the sales associate presenting it. Each and every diamond is chosen purely based on beauty. Our diamond buyers make sure each exquisite diamond is:

  • conflict-free in origin
  • beautiful
  • strong in structural integrity
  • top quality
  • never fracture filled or laser drilled
  • all independently certified

2. In-Store Experience

Let Our Diamond Experts Teach You Diamonds 101

Choosing an engagement ring is one of the most exciting times in a person’s life. However, it can be very nerve-racking. Let our experts at Gerald Peters alleviate your stress by doing all the work for you. Your diamond consultation entails a one-on-one conversation with one of our GIA-trained sales associates, who will educate you on the basics of diamonds and diamond purchasing, as well as help you to understand the concepts of color, clarity, cut, and carat. Once we have developed an understanding of your diamond preferences, we will schedule a follow up consultation.

Our top selections are then given to your consultant, who narrows down the selection to the best three diamonds. The owner of Gerald Peters then verifies the quality of the final selection, guaranteeing that the diamonds are perfect for your choosing.

During your second consultation, you are presented with the final hand-selected diamonds. We understand just how monumental and important this diamond purchase is, and our goal is to create a memorable and stress-free experience. Our main priority is to provide you with the perfect diamond for the perfect person.

3. Upgrade Policy

As your marriage grows, let us grow with you! We offer a wonderful trade-up policy for all customers in which you can upgrade your diamond to honor any momentous occasion. Special anniversary? We will give you a credit of 100% of the original purchase price of your diamond in exchange for a newer one of at least one (1) dollar greater in price. All you have to do is pay the difference to set a brand new diamond commemorating the new milestone you’ve reached with your loved one!

4. Hearts on Fire

Gerald Peters is proud to be Staten Island’s exclusive authorized retailer of Hearts on Fire’s “world’s most perfectly cut diamond!”

She’s perfect, so give her perfection.

Give her a Hearts On Fire diamond. The diamond cutting formula used by Hearts On Fire achieves maximum results with a perfect cut every single time. Each diamond is chosen from the top 1% of the world’s raw diamonds and then is cut and polished at 100X magnification, 10 times the industry standard. This results in perfect proportions, symmetry, polish and alignments, giving you the incomparable sparkle and brilliance that makes all the difference.

A Hearts On Fire diamond takes up to four times longer to cut than other diamonds and there are only 400 diamond cutters in the world who can master such perfection. Come check out our selection of Hearts On Fire diamonds in our store and see the difference for yourself.

Hearts on Fire